Supplements Reviewed Logo

Nutrition Geeks vs Elavate: Which Collagen Is Better?

A pure bovine collagen powder against a collagen superblend with added vitamins, probiotics and mushrooms. We compared dose, price and what's inside.


The Verdict

Our pick Nutrition Geeks Collagen Glow Up Powder Nutrition Geeks Collagen Glow Up Powder A+9.7/10 57p/serving
Elavate Multi Collagen Superblend Elavate Multi Collagen Superblend C+6.8/10 £2.45/serving

Nutrition Geeks wins 3 of 5 rounds, Elavate wins 1, 1 tied

Elavate packs a lot into its Superblend: bovine and marine collagen plus vitamin C, biotin, hyaluronic acid, probiotics and mushroom extracts. But you get 8g of collagen per serving at about £2.45, and a bag lasts around 20 days. Nutrition Geeks gives you 14g of collagen for 57p, and a pouch lasts 30 days. Elavate suits you if you want an all-in-one blend and don't mind the price.

Check Today's Price

✓ Free Next Day Delivery · ✓ 110,000+ Trustpilot reviews

Or shop Elavate

What Is Collagen and Why Do People Take It?

Collagen is the most abundant protein in the body, making up around a third of its total protein. It's the main structural protein in skin, bones, tendons and cartilage, and the body's own production slows as we get older.

Collagen supplements are made from hydrolysed collagen peptides: collagen broken down into small chains of amino acids such as glycine, proline and hydroxyproline so it dissolves easily in a drink. Most people take them as part of a daily routine alongside a balanced diet.

What to look for in a collagen supplement

Four things separate a good collagen supplement from an expensive one.

✓

A full dose in one serving

Most published studies use 2.5g to 15g of collagen peptides a day. Check how many grams of collagen you get per serving, not per pack. Capsules often contain under 1g each, so you'd need a handful a day to match one scoop of powder.

✓

Hydrolysed peptides, Type I & III

"Hydrolysed" means the collagen has been broken down into peptides that dissolve easily. Type I and Type III are the main types found in skin. Bovine collagen provides both, and marine collagen is mainly Type I.

✓

A short ingredients list

The best powders list one ingredient: collagen peptides. Sweeteners, flavourings and sugars add cost and make the powder harder to use in savoury food or coffee. Better filtering also means less smell and taste.

✓

Price per serving, not price per pack

A cheap tub with small servings can cost more per day than a bigger one. Divide the price by the number of full servings. Across our top five, the price ranged from 57p to £2.43 per serving.

What a collagen supplement can and can't promise

In Great Britain, supplements can only make health claims that are on the government's approved register. Collagen itself has no approved claims, so be wary of any brand that promises to remove wrinkles or fix joint pain. Here's what can be said:

  • Protein contributes to the maintenance of muscle mass and to the maintenance of normal bones. A high-protein collagen powder like our top pick (12.6g protein per serving) counts towards your daily protein.
  • Vitamin C contributes to normal collagen formation for the normal function of skin, bones, cartilage and blood vessels.
  • Biotin contributes to the maintenance of normal hair and skin, which is why some people pair collagen with a biotin supplement.

Side by Side

The key details from each brand's own label and website.

DetailNutrition GeeksElavate
Collagen per serving14g8.05g
Servings per pack30About 20
Price, one-off£16.99£49 (was £59)
Price per serving57pAbout £2.45
Collagen typeType I & III, bovineBovine and marine
Added nutrientsNoneVitamin C, biotin, hyaluronic acid, probiotics, mushrooms
FlavoursUnflavouredChocolate, vanilla, unflavoured
Made in the UKYesYes
DeliveryFree, next dayFree, next day
Subscribe & save10% off20% off

Green marks the better result in each row. Prices and details checked 29 October 2026 on each brand's own website.

Round by Round

Round 1

Collagen per serving

Nutrition Geeks wins
Nutrition Geeks14g
Elavate8.05g

Most published studies on collagen peptides use 2.5g to 15g a day. Nutrition Geeks gives you 14g a scoop; Elavate gives you 8.05g alongside its other ingredients.

Round 2

Price per serving

Nutrition Geeks wins
Nutrition Geeks57p
ElavateAbout £2.45

A £49 bag of Elavate lasts around 20 servings. A £16.99 pouch of Nutrition Geeks lasts 30, so each Elavate serving costs over four times as much.

Round 3

How long a pack lasts

Nutrition Geeks wins
Nutrition Geeks30 days
ElavateAbout 20 days

Nutrition Geeks lasts a full month at one scoop a day. An Elavate bag runs out after about three weeks.

Round 4

Added nutrients

Elavate wins
Nutrition GeeksCollagen only
ElavateVitamins, probiotics, mushrooms

Elavate adds vitamin C, which contributes to normal collagen formation for the normal function of skin, plus biotin, hyaluronic acid, probiotics and mushroom extracts. Nutrition Geeks is collagen only.

Round 5

Delivery

Tie
Nutrition GeeksFree, next day
ElavateFree, next day

Both brands deliver free the next day in the UK.

Which Should You Choose?

Choose Nutrition Geeks if...

  • You want the most collagen per serving (14g)
  • You want to pay 57p a serving rather than about £2.45
  • You'd like one ingredient you can add to any drink

Choose Elavate if...

  • You want an all-in-one blend with vitamins and probiotics
  • You'd like a chocolate or vanilla flavour
  • You're happy to pay more for the extra ingredients

Nutrition Geeks vs Elavate: FAQs

Is Elavate or Nutrition Geeks collagen better?

If you want collagen, Nutrition Geeks: 14g a serving for 57p, against 8.05g for about £2.45 with Elavate. Elavate is better if you want a flavoured all-in-one blend with vitamins, probiotics and mushroom extracts.

How many servings are in a bag of Elavate?

Elavate says a bag contains around 20 servings. A Nutrition Geeks pouch contains 30 servings of 14g.

Does the extra vitamin C matter?

Vitamin C contributes to normal collagen formation for the normal function of skin. You can get it from fruit and vegetables or a separate supplement, so it isn't a reason on its own to pay more for a blend.

Are they suitable for vegetarians?

No. Both contain collagen from animals (Elavate uses bovine and marine collagen), so neither is suitable for vegetarians or vegans.

Rebecca Thornton
About Rebecca Thornton

Rebecca researches and writes our supplement comparisons. For each guide she reads the product labels, checks list prices and delivery terms, reads verified customer reviews, and checks health wording against the GB register of approved claims.

Sources

  1. Department of Health and Social Care, Great Britain nutrition and health claims (NHC) register, gov.uk.
  2. Nutrition Geeks, Collagen Glow Up Powder product page, nutritiongeeks.co, checked 29 October 2026.
  3. Elavate, Multi Collagen Superblend product page, elavatecollagen.com, checked 29 October 2026.

Our Pick: Nutrition Geeks

Nutrition Geeks Collagen Glow Up Powder

Nutrition Geeks Collagen Glow Up gives you 14g of triple-filtered, grass-fed bovine collagen per serving, with nothing else added. At 57p a serving with free next day delivery, it beat Elavate on dose, price and how long a pack lasts.

Check Today's Price

✓ Free Next Day Delivery · ✓ 110,000+ Trustpilot reviews

Our pick: Nutrition Geeks Collagen9.7/10 · 57p/serving
Check Price